Jeffersonville Indiana Insurance Agency

Your Locally Owned & Trusted Independent Insurance Agency
Located in Jeffersonville, Indiana providing custom insurance solutions for all of Indiana and Kentucky. Are you looking for better car insurance in Indiana? How about homeowners or business? At Innovators Insurance, we can handle whatever insurance you need, fast, and friendly!



Unlike captive or direct insurance companies and agencies, who have limited choices and options for your insurance needs, Innovators Insurance Group is different. We’re a 100% independent insurance agency, meaning we work for YOU.


We partner with some of the highest-rated insurance companies in the country to provide you choices and options for your insurance. We have a team of experts who go above and beyond in service and guidance, and who truly care about protecting individuals, families and businesses in Southern Indiana and Louisville.


We do the heavy lifting for you.


What’s more, you don’t have to lift a finger. We’ll review your current coverage and provide you with a detailed comparison, giving you our recommendations and showing you all of your available coverage and pricing options.


insurance agency Jeffersonville, Indiana

Nathan Ramsey

Personal Insurance Customer

Daniel and his team did a great job finding a good deal on our home and car insurance. They are easy to work with and very personable. I’m glad I went with them instead of doing it on my own.

insurance agency Jeffersonville, Indiana

Amelia Voelker

Personal Insurance Customer

Daniel has been a great agent and helped us through changing our car and homeowners insurance when buying our first home!

insurance agency Jeffersonville, Indiana

Sherri Sampson

Personal Insurance Customer

Daniel, owner of Innovator Insurance Group, has wowed me with his customer service since day 1. He and his staff are knowledgeable, timely, and make sure the client is well informed and well protected. I recommend Innovators Insurance to everyone!!

insurance agency Jeffersonville, Indiana

Keaton Roggenkamp

Personal Insurance Customer

Innovators is absolutely fantastic to work with. They got us a cheaper rate with more coverage. Can't beat the friendly customer service and flexibility of product offerings!


We'll shop and compare for you, saving you time, aggravation, and money!


Being Independent means that we don't work for any one insurance company. We have the ability to search multiple companies on your behalf, acting as a negotiator, to find you the best possible policy and price. You never have to haggle with an agent or insurance company again.


Not all insurance agencies are created equal. We have an in-depth knowledge of insurance policy coverages from dozens of different insurance companies. We've seen it all, and when it comes to fine print, we truly understand the coverage we are recommending.


Why sit on hold with a call center representative who doesn't know you, when you can deal with a familiar face who knows you and understands your unique situation? Our customer service is the single biggest reason why our customers refer us so many of their friends.


The entire reason you have insurance is for when you need to use it. Unfortunately, insurance contracts contain many exclusions and conditions you may be unaware of. We'll help you understand how you're covered, and walk you through your claim.


When you do business with our agency, you're not only supporting your local community, but you're being serviced by a local business who knows your name, and your unique coverage needs. You never have to deal with call-center representatives again.


Our process is to do insurance better. To make it easy and frictionless for you. Insurance is really important...when you need it. We hope you never need it, but IF you do it’s important that you have the right coverage and the right team guiding you through everything.


Our focus is YOU and on being a valued part of our community. We love being able to help so many individuals, families and businesses in Jeffersonville and Louisville and across all of Southern Indiana.


Our process is designed to bring you true value, and is fully tailored to your specific insurance needs. We give you choices and options so that you can obtain the freedom of elite security and protection, while not overpaying for your insurance. And we fully take everything off your plate so that you can live your life knowing your insurance is in good hands.

Insurance News From Our Agency Blog

specialty dwelling insurance Jeffersonville IN

5 Rules Every Landlord Should Live By

By austin | March 16, 2017

I’m pretty confident that if you asked anyone who has ever owned a rental property you would get an overwhelming response that it’s not as lucrative or easy as they thought it would be. In fact, owning a rental property can be a major pain, and end up costing you a ton of money! I […]

insurance quotes Jeffersonville IN

Will my credit rating change my insurance rates?

By austin | February 2, 2017

I was recently asked this question by one of our Innovators Insurance Group clients, and thought I would share the answer here for our readers. There are a lot of things that go into homeowners and auto insurance rates, one of them being credit. I’ve heard a lot of complaints from people who don’t like the […]

Why Do My Auto Insurance Rates Keep Going Up Even Though My Car Keeps Getting Older?

By austin | February 2, 2017

Why do my auto insurance rates keep going up even though my car is getting older?  At Innovators Insurance Group, many of our clients ask this question so I would like to address it from a couple of angles. First things first, even though it’s called car/auto insurance, it covers more than just your car. […]

Call Email Claims Client Login